Ify, love your list, but my list would slide everything down 1 but the Good, the Bad, & the Ugly and put Once Upon A Time in the West 2nd. Love that movie. Also take your number 9 and 10 off and put in Fistful of Dollars and For a few Dollars more. That would be my list.
Yeah, I had a hard time after my top 5, but in the end I had to sacrifice the first two in the Dollars trilogy. The reason being, although my heart was telling to go with them, my head was saying “well which films are the most accomplished?”, hence I chose Proposition and Rio Bravo. Check out my original list on page 1, I guess as time has gone by, my views on the the first two Dollars films have lessened. I need to watch films 7-10 on my list again though, they may change places after that.