The Quentin Tarantino Archives logo

The Basterds


#1

Ok, Aldo Rayne, Donny Donowitz and Hugo Stiglitz are the main basterds, but in what order whould we rank the other ones in terms of their importence to the plot? I whould say:

1.Omar Ulmer

2.Smithson Utivich

3.Wilhelm Wicki

4.Gerold Hirschberg

5.Michael Zimmerman

6.Andy Kagan

7.Simon Sakowitz


#2

Omar didn’t have THAT much to do with the plot. It could have been any basterd. I’d definitely put him below Wiki and Utivich.


#3

[quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”]Omar didn’t have THAT much to do with the plot. It could have been any basterd. I’d definitely put him below Wiki and Utivich.[/quote]

But he still did more important stuff than Wiki and Utivich. What did Utivich and Wiki do that were important to the plot?


#4

[quote=“VikingWithNoName”][quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”]Omar didn’t have THAT much to do with the plot. It could have been any basterd. I’d definitely put him below Wiki and Utivich.[/quote]

But he still did more important stuff than Wiki and Utivich. What did Utivich and Wiki do that were important to the plot?[/quote]

Wiki was one of the german-speakers, so he was very important. And Utivich had a nickname, so he was more important. :smiley:



Omar didn’t REALLY need to be there. Donny could have pulled all that off on his own.


#5

[quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”][quote=“VikingWithNoName”][quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”]Omar didn’t have THAT much to do with the plot. It could have been any basterd. I’d definitely put him below Wiki and Utivich.[/quote]

But he still did more important stuff than Wiki and Utivich. What did Utivich and Wiki do that were important to the plot?[/quote]

Wiki was one of the german-speakers, so he was very important. And Utivich had a nickname, so he was more important. :smiley:



Omar didn’t REALLY need to be there. Donny could have pulled all that off on his own.[/quote]

The entire thing with Omar was that he was just a random guy among the basterds. Quentin could have used Hirshberg or Zimmerman or Andy Kagan. That was what i liked with the movie. The random soldier got important. And Donny whould never been able to do it without help. O0


#6

[quote=“VikingWithNoName”]


The entire thing with Omar was that he was just a random guy among the basterds. Quentin could have used Hirshberg or Zimmerman or Andy Kagan. That was what i liked with the movie. The random soldier got important. And Donny whould never been able to do it without help. O0[/quote]

Oh, see, that’s why I felt Omar wasn’t more important… Because it could have been any of them. I still say Wiki is like the number 4 guy. :wink:


#7

[quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”][quote=“VikingWithNoName”]


The entire thing with Omar was that he was just a random guy among the basterds. Quentin could have used Hirshberg or Zimmerman or Andy Kagan. That was what i liked with the movie. The random soldier got important. And Donny whould never been able to do it without help. O0[/quote]

Oh, see, that’s why I felt Omar wasn’t more important… Because it could have been any of them. I still say Wiki is like the number 4 guy. :wink:[/quote]

I still think we should rank them for that they did, Omar killed Goebbels, talked with good italian accent and made the Eastern Condors run. Wiki cut a dudes throat and… sat silent in a bar.


#8

And translated english to german during the interrogation scene.


#9

[quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”]And translated english to german during the interrogation scene.[/quote]


You are right. He is more important than Utivich. :smiley:


#10

Wicki could have kicked Omar’s puny little ass. :laugh:


#11

[quote=“Kinick”]Wicki could have kicked Omar’s puny little ass. :laugh:[/quote]


:laugh: I concur.

#12

[quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”][quote=“Kinick”]Wicki could have kicked Omar’s puny little ass. :laugh:[/quote]


:laugh: I concur.[/quote]

Yes he whould. If they made a prequel they should give him more space. And Andy Kagan. He was bad ass. Just look at his face then he killed that nazi in the prison.


#13

the translator > the little man > Omar > Samm Levine >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the rest (almost nonexistant)


#14

It may also be worth noting that in the original script it was Hirschberg, not Omar, who went with Donny and Aldo to the theatre.


#15

[quote=“Tornmuscle”]It may also be worth noting that in the original script it was Hirschberg, not Omar, who went with Donny and Aldo to the theatre.[/quote]

I know that. I think he changed that becouse the script leaked out. Levine was cool as Hirschberg, hope we get to see more og him later on.


#16

[quote=“VikingWithNoName”][quote=“Tornmuscle”]It may also be worth noting that in the original script it was Hirschberg, not Omar, who went with Donny and Aldo to the theatre.[/quote]

I know that. I think he changed that becouse the script leaked out. Levine was cool as Hirschberg, hope we get to see more og him later on.[/quote]


I think he changed it cos he has a mancrush on Omar Doom.

#17

[quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”][quote=“VikingWithNoName”][quote=“Tornmuscle”]It may also be worth noting that in the original script it was Hirschberg, not Omar, who went with Donny and Aldo to the theatre.[/quote]

I know that. I think he changed that becouse the script leaked out. Levine was cool as Hirschberg, hope we get to see more og him later on.[/quote]


I think he changed it cos he has a mancrush on Omar Doom.[/quote]
Hahahahahaha!! :D

By the way Geoi, was there not a basterd who was supposed to be called Geoi?

#18

[quote=“VikingWithNoName”][quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”]




I think he changed it cos he has a mancrush on Omar Doom.[/quote]


Hahahahahaha!! :D

By the way Geoi, was there not a basterd who was supposed to be called Geoi?[/quote]

Indeed there was. However, I felt it would be too obvious, so I asked Quentin to cut him out. :stuck_out_tongue:


#19

[quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”][quote=“VikingWithNoName”][quote=“Sgt. Geoi Donowitz”]




I think he changed it cos he has a mancrush on Omar Doom.[/quote]


Hahahahahaha!! :D

By the way Geoi, was there not a basterd who was supposed to be called Geoi?[/quote]

Indeed there was. However, I felt it would be too obvious, so I asked Quentin to cut him out. :stuck_out_tongue:[/quote]

So what basterd was called Geoi? I have a slite memory of that being Utvich.


#20

Hahaha :laugh: Some noob lurker is going to read this and think it’s true.